On Nov. 3, Google said it would change the defaults for four products in schools. Gemini, Gemini Notebook, Gemini in Classroom and Google Search "will be entirely off for K-12 student accounts until school administrators explicitly turn them on," the company wrote in a blog post.
That sounds like what many districts asked for after Google switched Gemini on for many students in August. The catch came in an interview. "[S]earch and A.I. are deeply integrated," Chris Phillips, Google's vice president and general manager of education, told The New York Times, and schools that ban AI "will not have access to search" (CNN). There is no setting for traditional Google searches without AI summaries (Education Week).
Here is what administrators will actually be able to control, based on what Google has said so far.
What you can switch on and off
Product | Default for K-12 student accounts | What turning it on means |
|---|---|---|
Gemini app | Off | Students get Google's AI chatbot |
Gemini Notebook | Off | Students get Google's AI notebook tool |
Gemini in Classroom | Off | Gemini inside Classroom, including teacher-assigned Guided Learning activities |
Google Search | Off | Search returns, with AI Overviews and AI Mode included; there is no AI-free option |
Google's blog post lists all four products. Its later post on X named three (Gemini, Gemini Notebook and Search) as separately switchable.
Google says it will "share more specifics with schools in the coming months ahead of the changes rolling out" (Google). Phillips said the changes will start early next year (Education Week), and NBC 7 San Diego reports that districts face a January deadline to decide (NBC 7).
Search without Gemini: yes. Search without AI: no
The first round of coverage suggested schools had to accept Gemini to keep Search. Google walked that back the same day. In a post on X, it said the changes "give schools more choice, not less," and that schools can "turn on one, two, or all of these services individually" (Gizmodo). "They are separate controls," Google spokesman Davis Thompson confirmed in an email (GovTech).
So a district can turn on Search and leave the Gemini chatbot off. What it cannot do is turn on Search without the AI built into it: AI Overviews, the summaries at the top of results, and AI Mode, the chatbot-style search. For students, Google says those features will offer "step-by-step guided learning through problems" instead of quick answers (Education Week).
Settings can differ by grade
Administrators get "two levels of control," Phillips said in a Nov. 2 virtual meeting: leave Search and Gemini off, or turn either or both on and let students use Guided Learning, Google's AI study mode (Education Week).
Brittany Siegal Mennuti, Google's product lead for Classroom, said a district could bar AI for one group of students, limit another to Guided Learning, and give older students "the full-fledged search experience" with the usual AI summaries. Any group barred from AI also loses Search (Education Week).
A grade-band plan might look like this:
Grade band | Search | Gemini | What students get |
|---|---|---|---|
Early grades | Off | Off | No Google Search; teachers use other research tools |
Middle grades | On, Guided Learning | Off | Search with AI that coaches instead of answering |
High school | On | On | Full Search experience and the Gemini chatbot |
Example only. Google has not yet published the admin settings, so check the final options before you plan around them.
Why districts are wary of AI in Search
In July, Common Sense Media gave the AI features in Google Search an "unacceptable risk" rating for kids and teens (Gizmodo). In one test, AI Mode completed all 180 homework assignments researchers gave it. Google disputed the assessment, saying it used "a narrow set of ambiguous and contrived queries" (eWeek).
Google says Guided Learning will address the homework problem. The Search version starts as a pilot in select U.S. schools this month, and Guided Learning in Classroom is already available (Google). Yvette Renteria, chief program officer at Common Sense Media, said "it's really too soon to be able to launch something like this tool without really vetting it thoroughly" (Education Week).
"Having Google Search without AI search is the best option," Renteria said. "And it's unfortunately an option that Google is not providing to schools or districts" (Education Week).
How districts are responding
- New York City and Los Angeles had already restricted generative AI before the announcement. New York City banned student-facing AI through 8th grade, and Los Angeles Unified imposed a one-year moratorium on generative AI on its devices (Education Week). L.A. Unified said it is "reviewing Google's announcement and its potential implications" (EdSource via Times of San Diego).
- Oceanside Unified (California) plans to keep using Google Search and has been expanding AI access gradually as students get older (NBC 7).
- San Diego Unified blocks chatbots on district Chromebooks. "Chat bots like the Ask Gemini feature ChatGPT, Claude, OpenAI ... Those are not accessible on our district-issued Chromebook devices," said Nicole DeWitt, deputy superintendent of instruction. The district said it is "still evaluating the effects of Google's new policy" (NBC 7).
- Long Beach Unified is gathering input from a new tech policy group of parents, teachers, students, administrators and industry experts, and is surveying students about AI use (EdSource via Times of San Diego).
- Fairfax County Public Schools (Virginia) is testing its own Chrome extension that hides AI Overviews, and the filtering company Securly offers a feature to block AI content in Google searches (Education Week). Renteria warned that smaller districts "may not have the personnel" to build workarounds (Education Week).
The backlash
New York City Mayor Zohran Mamdani wrote that "[n]o corporation should have the power to dictate how we teach our children," and Sen. Bernie Sanders called the policy "extortion." Former Federal Trade Commission Chair Lina Khan wrote that Google "is using its search monopoly to coerce schools into adopting AI" (Education Week). Google's position is that schools are now in control and that the defaults start from off (Forbes).
What to do before the rollout
Sources
- Responsible AI for schools with Guided Learning. Google (2026)
- Google’s New Rules Hand Schools Hard Choices About AI and Search. Education Week (2026)
- Google will let schools turn off AI, but they may also lose Search. CNN (2026)
- Google Reverses Decision to Turn Off Search for Schools Not Using AI. GovTech (2026)
- Google Tries to Walk Back Controversial School AI Policy Following Political Backlash. Gizmodo (2026)
- Google Leverages Search Against K-12 Schools Opting Out Of AI. Forbes (via Yahoo Tech) (2026)
- Google AI policy forces decision for San Diego schools. NBC 7 San Diego (2026)
- Google’s new AI ‘ultimatum’ sparks concern over tech giant’s power in California schools. EdSource (via Times of San Diego) (2026)
- Google Disputes Child-Safety Report on AI Search as Control Gap Persists. eWeek (2026)

